January 7, 2026

How Does A Claim Affect Your Insurance Premium?

One of the most common questions we hear is: ‘If I make a claim, will by insurance go up?”

The answer depends on several factors – but understanding how claims impact premiums can help you make informed decisions.

How Insurance Premiums Are Calculated

Your premium is based on risk. Insurance companies consider:

  • Claims history
  • Type of claim
  • Frequency of claims
  • Driving record (for auto)
  • Property risk factors (for home)
  • Industry and operations (for business insurance)

A claims-free history often qualifies you for discounts or preferred rates.

When a Claim May Impact Your Premium

Not every claim leads to a rate increase. However, premiums may change if:

  • You are found at fault in an auto accident
  • You file multiple claims within a short period
  • The claim indicates increased future risk

For example, several water damage claims may signal a maintenance issue that insurers view as ongoing risk exposure.

Claims That May Not Affect Your Rate

Some situations may have minimal impact, such as:

  • The cost of repairs vs. your deductible
  • Potential impact on your long-term premium
  • Whether the loss exceeds what you can reasonably pay out-of-pocket

Your broker can help you weigh these factors.

At McFarlan Rowlands, we believe in helping clients make informed decisions – not just reacting in the moment.

If you’re unsure whether to file a claim, contact us first. We’ll walk you through your options.